Jack Finney wrote one of my favorite time travel books, Time and Again, in 1970. The protagonist, Simon Morley, is asked to participate in a time-travel experiment developed by Dr. Danziger for the government. (Right away you know there is going to be a problem. When has government involvement ever improved anything.) Simon travels back to 1882; lands inside the Dakota in NYC. Grover Cleveland is President, the Statue of Liberty is sitting in pieces around the island, waiting to be assembled and real babies are drugged and used in department store windows for marketing purposes. As the story evolves, there’s a secondary plot regarding a historical murder, steeped with mystery, that includes a blackmail scheme and a massive fire. The murder mystery itself reverberates through the years to the present. Last, there is Danziger’s touching tale of his parents’ first accidental cute meet at the theater in 1882, which led to their subsequent marriage and, of course, to him.
As anticipated, Simon falls in love with 1882 and with Julia, but Simon's descriptions of the World Wars, the uprising of Castro (and the book’s historically accurate depictions of these events) cause Julia to want nothing to do with the 20th century. Simon wants to live with Julia in 1882 but the government will not allow Simon to do so. Danziger, in the interim, likewise has come to disagree with the government’s handling of his program and how it wants to change the past for a better future. Much drama and plot twists ensue, until Simon recalls how Danziger famously talked of his parents’ first accidental meeting, so you know which way this book will wrap up.
Could there be a movie or two here, you say to yourself. Absolutely. Remember Somewhere In Time, one of the most romantic time travel movies of all time. Christopher Reeve lives in the present. Through some fluke in the universe, his character lands in 1912 and falls in love with Jane Seymour's character. My heart ached every time that 1979 penny appeared and sent him away from her. As an old lady, in his present, she asks him to come back to her. Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini; still one of the most haunting compositions by Rachmaninoff, plays throughout the movie. How can anyone not believe in time travel after reading that book and watching that movie?
Some years ago, we arrived at Mackinac Island via ferry, where the movie was filmed. I stepped inside the Grand Hotel hoping for some residual magic; ghosts traversing through fairy dust motes, sailing between the afternoon sun’s changing rays, but the only thing we discovered was that the Grand Hotel did not have air conditioning and no car traffic was allowed on the island. It was hot and humid and we walked or rode a bicycle.
Another book, Einstein’s Dreams by Alan Lightman, in a collection of short stories, discussed Einstein’s theory of special relativity, which suggested that time passes at different rates for different people. One story tells how time travels so slowly while waiting for an engagement with a pretty girl, and how quickly time passes once she has arrived, while another story about a world without a future takes place only in the present. The stories are all about ‘what if’ time does this and that happens or if time does that and this happens. Also, the book is not long, so there isn’t much chance that your brain will explode with all the new thoughts and ideas that the book may counsel.
One of Lightman’s stories is about the same day taking place again and again with different outcomes at the end of each day. How many times have we said to ourselves ‘if only I had done this, or done that’, the outcome would have been so different. Are there movies to coincide with Lightman’s book. As expected, there are dozens of them; remember Groundhog Day, Edge of Tomorrow, or Run Lola Run. And, in fact, if I had not waited an extra five minutes, I would not have met my husband, but I did wait and have been the happier for it. Time was on my side.
Recently I emailed a very old photo of our school crowd to a friend. His immediate response was: “who says time travel is not possible”. We were both right there again, in that picture, young and fresh, on the brink of adulthood, with our entire lives in front of us. Is remembering a moment in the past the same as time travel. “If we could do it all again, would we, could we. . . . “ When we look up at a star, we are not seeing it as it is in the present, but as it existed millions of years ago.